Saturday, June 22, 2024

The 2024 Decanter Awards - South African Gold and Silver Medallists

The results of the 2024 Decanter Awards competition have been released. 530 South African wines earned medals. Of these, two were awarded Best in Show, 1 Platinum, 28 Gold, 220 Silver and 282 Bronze. The whole story can be seen HERE 

There are many wine competitions, several in South Africa, but this is one of the most highly respected and it judges the wines blind against their peers from all the wine-producing countries. While respecting their opinions, it must be remembered that all wine judging is subject to many influences - emotion, atmosphere, personal prejudice, national pride and taste preferences.... Some of the results in the table below tally quite closely with results in South African competitions such as, most recently the Investec Trophy Wine Show, and others have quite large differences. That is the nature of the beast.

Entry into the Decanter Awards costs £170 (R3862) plus 20% VAT per entry and four sample bottles are required per wine entry. This is obviously a very serious consideration for producers, especially the smaller ones, and that is without the cost of getting the entries to the publishers of the magazine or the cost of buying bottle stickers for winning wines - £55 (R1250) per roll of 1000.

On the subject of scoring, the current favourite system is scoring wines out of 100. We are, perhaps, old-fashioned, but we agree with the opinion recently expressed by Tim James that it is too exact for something which is subject to the influences above. The Decanter site shows scores out of 100. In the table we show here, we have added a column in which the scores are converted to scores out of 20.

Not many years ago, a wine scoring 90 (18/20) would have earned a Gold medal. The standard has risen, Gold is in a narrow band between 96 and 95 (19/20) and a score between 94 and 90 is only worthy of Silver. The bottom line is that any wine which scores 90 or above is worthy of consideration. Two of the Gold medallists, Spier Albariño at R85 and MAN Family Vintners Essay Red Blend at R115 (ex cellars), have an additional note that they are Good Value which, in Britain, means that a bottle sells for less than £15 (±R330). British retail prices are taken into consideration in the judging.

Stellenbosch wines were the best performers, obviously with the most entries, and they scored 181 medals in all categories but there was a good spread of Gold and Silver medals across our principal wine producing regions. It was good to see one of our favourites, Oak Valley's Groenlandberg Chardonnay earning a Platinum medal. We were pleased to see how many MCCs won medals.

You may notice some unfamiliar labels such as wines with the names of British supermarkets, Aldi, Asda and Marks & Spencer may or may not be available here (such as M&S Creation Chardonnay).

You can see the Gold and Silver medallists here:

All our stories can be seen in the Blog Archive near the top of the column on the right

If you do not wish to receive e-mails from us, please email menucape@gmail.com with the word 'UNSUBSCRIBE' in your email



Wednesday, June 19, 2024

Wine Concepts Grape Escape wine festival at Moyo, Kirstenbosch

Michael Bampfield Duggan of Wine Concepts' annual tasting of unusual varietals really appeals to us
Our winelands are becoming more diverse; it's where we have to go if we are to grow and prosper
while Global warming takes its toll of traditional vineyards worldwide
And we love tasting diversity
However, this was a huge tasting of many different wines so, sadly, we could only manage to taste a selection of them
There were so many tempting white wines that, regrettably, we could only taste a very small sample of red wines

It was held, this year, at Moyo Restaurant at Kirstenbosch
It is a superb venue, wide and spacious
and accommodating all the farms comfortably who wanted to show off their diversity in wine

It was raining and the mountain streams were in full spate when we arrived

The entrance

Mike at the entrance table with his trusty staff

The huge room with the double sided fireplace mid room and some great chandeliers to provide good lighting

André Badenhorst, showing the after effects of a motoring incident, had some good wines on show, made by his son Adi
André is fine, thankfully
The Kalmoesfontein White blend 2021 has Grenache blanc, Chenin, Roussanne, Viognier
all adding to this crisp and fulsome blend which cries "food please"! 

And Secateurs 2021 Chenin Blanc, which is deservedly on most menus in the Cape and a best seller,
never disappoints with its quality of great Swartland Chenin

A good selection of Bruce Jack's wines. We especially loved the 2023 Reserve Viognier,
full of peach blossom and promise and, on the palate, the intensity of peaches with cream with a dash of crisp lemon,
so good with spicy food or just to enjoy glass by glass

Ginny Poval's Botanica wines always impress
and the Mary Delaney 2022 Chenin Blanc from Citrusdal has texture layered with ripe golden fruit and rewards

The M&S 2021 Ogier Cote du Rhône was a good find in the tasting;
it has such a French nose and attitude and needs pairing with food

The Cedarberg Five Generations Chenin blanc has golden fruit and lime in layer after layer

The Cedarberg Sauvignon Gris was life changing
It is grey on the nose with some of the expected varietal aromas,
but so different on the palate, like a rush of fresh breeze,
crisp and dry with some green leaves blowing in it, with excitement
We scored both very highly


Winemaker WS Visagie showed the Daschbosch Méthode Ancestrale sparkling wine
The Verdelho grapes are from 62 year old vines in the Breedekloof
And you can see from the label that he took a flier at this and its a success
Interesting, initially crisp and sparkling, with lots of fruit, some cooked, apples, limes and greengage plum

Three of the Daschbosch wines

Canapés. Unusual but good crisp onion leaves in batter

Darling Cellars with their wealth of good unusual varietals, we must make an other visit soon
Their Rosés are a summer standard in our house

Fairview's Viognier was the first ever produced in South Africa by talented winemaker Anthony de Jager
and it is still a great rendition of this lovely grape
Bloemcool Ploegstert white blend is a blend of Palomino, Chenin Blanc and Grenache Blanc

Margot Nel and Leon Coetzee showed their Hoeksteen Chenin blanc and Boplaas Verdelho,
both excellent examples of their class

Jason Steel's Lorraine Allison Rosé from Cinsault

Jordan's Timepiece range has added a Riesling. Sadly, the Assyrtiko is sold out at the cellar
We hope to taste the new vintage soon, its a great wine

Nicole Kilian with the Keermont wines

Three of Kleine Zalze Project Z wines;
the Chenin Blanc 2021, the Chenin Blanc Skin Contact 2021 and the Project Z Sweet Fortified NV
and their Cellar Selection Cinsault Rosé

Alexandra MacFarlane showed several of her wines
Impressive was the The Capitoline Wolf White blend 70% Semillon and 30% Chenin Blanc
As expected from Semillon, it is grey on the nose and waxy on the palate
It has Aladdin coming out of the bottle with lovely crisp and zingy fruit coming with him! Surprise and so enjoyable

The Capitoline Wolf Rosé, The Capitoline Wolf Red blend, The Capitoline Wolf White blend,
Monday's Child Chenin blanc and Tuesdays Child Cinsault

Morgenster's Vermentino is a firecracker of a wine, with superb minerality - a wine suited  for seafood and fish

Emy Mathews was showing Morgenster's excellent Tristis Vermentino

Mont Rachelle's 2023 Little Rock Blanc

Michael Bampfield Duggan with Billy Hughes and winemaker Lieze Norval of Nativo wines

Two wines from Neil Joubert, Good to see the 2023 Grüner Veltliner and the 2019 Grenache Blanc

Henry Kotzé and Angie Tieling showed the Nomoya wines of Michela Sfiligoi and Agronomist Attilio Dalpiaz,
whom we first met when they were at Ayama in Voor Paardeberg

The Nomoya 2021 Chenin Blanc and the 2021 Vermentino

Three wines from Org de Rac: Roussanne 2022, De Waghuis Wit 2021 and De Waghuis Rooi 2021

Alisa van der Westhuizen showing the wines of Org de Rac

Painted Wolf had their Solo Roussanne 2023, Lycaon Old Vine Chenin Blanc, 2021 always a stunner,
and Blacktip Mourvedre 2020

Roodekrantz wines

Usana wines

The excellent Stellenrust Chenin blancs, White and Red Cinsault and a Shiraz

Strandveld charmed with their Skaamgesiggie Pinot Brut Cap Classic 2020; their other wines are always superb

Their Viognier is always worth tasting and buying
Their Adamastor Bordeaux blend of crisp and elegant Sauvignon Blanc and Semillon is on many top wine lists

Yes samosas and some were mince,
but they produced a great new invention, a samosa stuffed full of rich melting cheese
Wow. Just right after tasting quite a lot of wine

VDP Distributors had some interesting wines. The Lothian Elgin Grüner Veltliner 2023 was so enjoyable
The Lemberg Harslevelu has been unique to the estate in Tulbagh since the 1980s and is signature for the farm
We wish we'd had time to taste the others

Welgegund in Wellington had a good range of their wines
and the Old Vines 2021 Cinsault is heady and rich on the nose and palate with beautiful fruit and supporting tannins
Deserves time in the cellar

Iona in Elgin has one of the best Nebbiolos, their 2019
It's very Italian in style, but perhaps even better!
Such good fruit in layers but true to its varietal identity. So good with food

Paul Gibon from Arromanches in Normandy with the South African Italian Idiom wines,
coincidentally on the anniversary of the D Day landings in France

Their 2020 Viognier has lots of oak,
the 2019 Zinfandel has geranium on the nose, salty minerality and long fruit layers with cherry and mulberry
Needs food NOW!

All our stories can be seen in the Blog Archive near the top of the column on the right

If you do not wish to receive e-mails from us, please email menucape@gmail.com with the word 'UNSUBSCRIBE' in your email

The 2024 Investec Trophy Wine Awards at Glen Carlou

 The venue for the 2024 Awards was Glen Carlou estate near Paarl on the road to Franschhoek

Several good Cap Classiques on offer as we arrived


Canapés and bubbly were served in the Art Gallery which gave us all a chance to admire the art and chat to friends





Melba toast squares with roasted peppers
There was also a canapé of local smoked trout that was absolutely delicious,
oh so crispy pork belly and glasses of warm pea soup
All good, all unique and well done

Head Judge and originator of the competition Michael Fridjhon welcomed us and got things going

All the trophies were on display

Georgie Alexander, Investec High Net Worth International Leader,
spoke about Investec's involvement and presented the trophies for the Trophy wines
She explained how she did understand the wine industry as she is married to it;
her husband has an important position in it, but they keep their business lives very separate
The world is at last recognising the value of South African wine
She quoted Jim Harrison: "“The simple act of opening a bottle of wine has brought more happiness to the human race
than all the collective governments in the history of earth”
Her message to the winemakers who had been invited was "Enjoy the day, you richly deserve it" 

Her colleague Liane le Roux, Banking Team Leader, presented the gold medals

The Gold Medal winners
Back Row L to R:
Brad Paton (Buitenverwachting), Annemi Nel (De Krans Tritonia Calitzdorp Blend 2022, Jean Nel (Cederberg Shiraz 2020), Neil Bruwer (Chamonix Premier White Reserve 2022), Hagen Viljoen (Zevenwacht Z Collection Sauvignon Blanc 2023), Pieter Carstens (Leeuwenkuil Heritage Chenin Blanc 2020), Philip Viljoen (Bon Courage Inkará Cabernet Sauvignon 2019), Ewen Wilson (Lothian of Elgin Chardonnay 2021)
 Front Row L to R:

Johnny Calitz (Glen Carlou Chardonnay 2023), Kobus vd Merwe (KWV Cathedral Cellar Sauvignon Blanc 2023), RJ Botha (Kleine Zalze Vintage Brut Chardonnay Pinot Noir Cap Classique 2017), Narina Cloete (Blaauwklippen Chardonnay 2023), Margaux Nel (Boplaas Cape Vintage Reserve Port 2006), Dudley Wilson (Lothian of Elgin Chardonnay 2021)

Misty rain covering the winter vines

The menu. We needed to make only one choice and that was of the main course
The starter, warm Parmesan cheese soufflé, was delicious 

The very long, impressive wine list can be seen at the end of this story
Seared Salmon, topped with a good horseradish sauce, roast potatoes and cucumber relish
was high quality salmon, moist and so well cooked 

The Lamb shoulder had been deconstructed and was served with a crisp fondant potato, and al dente vegetables

Michael Fridjhon and Georgie Alexander about to begin the Trophy awards

Alex Mason-Gordon was doing the honours of handing them to Georgie Alexander
They had been kept secret until the moment of presentation

This was such a good venue for the awards, spacious, with great views and very attentive and professional staff
We were surprised to hear that this was the first time it had been used as an outside awards venue

JC le Roux winemaker Matthys Botes received Trophies for
JC Le Roux Méthode Cap Classique Scintilla Vintage Reserve 2015
 and Pongrácz Méthode Cap Classique Chardonnay Blanc de Blancs NV

Winemaker Rudi Schultz received a Trophy for the Best Museum Class Sauvignon blanc
for Thelema Sauvignon Blanc Reserve 2015

The barrel cellar seen through the glass section of the restaurant floor,
which does cause moments of vertigo for some! 

José Conde received a Trophy for Stark-Condé Round Mountain Sauvignon Blanc 2023

Bloemendal winemaker Andri Hanekom received the
Trophy for the Best Museum Class Sauvignon Semillon blend for Bloemendal Kanonberg 2018
and Trophy for the best Museum class Semillon for Bloemendal Semillon 2017

Thor Vintners owner/winemaker Emile Gentis received a Trophy for Thor Lara Semillon 2023

Cape Point winemaker Anzele Visser with Trophy for Cape Point Vineyards Isliedh 2022 Sauvignon Semillon blend

Trophy designer John Skotnes

Trophy for Best Other White Blend received by Schenkfontein winemaker Jurgen Siebritz and owner Hendrik Hanekom

The Harold Eedes Trophy for Best Chenin Blanc
was awarded to KWV Head winemaker Kobus van der Merwe by Anthea Eedes

Trophy for Best Museum Class Cabernet sauvignon was received by winemaker Corlea Fourie
for Bosman Cabernet Sauvignon 2013

Trophy for Best Cabernet Sauvignon was received by cellarmaster RJ Botha
for Kleine Zalze Vineyard Selection Cabernet Sauvignon 2021

Head winemaker Izele van Blerk received a Trophy for KWV The Mentors Canvas 2020 Mediterranean red blend

Trophy for Best Pinotage was presented to Durbanville Hills winemaker Wilhelm Coetzee
for the Durbanville Hills Collectors Reserve The Promenade Pinotage 2022
which he made with the late Martin Moore

The glass Riedel Trophy  for Best Bordeaux style Red Blend,
a huge glass which can contain a whole bottle of wine. It has to be looked after very carefully

Michael Crossley presented the Riedel Trophy to Hagen Viljoen
for Zevenwacht Z Reserve Collection 2021

The Trophy for Best Dessert Wine was presented to winemaker Jamie Williams
for Nederburg The Winemasters Noble Late Harvest 2023

The Crème Brulée was such a good way to end an excellent meal

Winemaker Zinaschke Steyn received Trophies
for Nederburg The Winemasters Noble Late Harvest 2023 Unfortified Dessert
and Nederburg The Winemasters Shiraz 2022

Viticulturist Kallie Fernhout received the Vinolok Trophy for the highest-scoring premium-priced gold medallist
for the Delaire Graff Estate Banghoek Chardonnay 2022 which also won Trophy for Best Chardonnay,
Investec International Judges’ Trophy and Investec Trophy for Best White Wine overall
He also received the Tony Mossop Trophy for Best Cape Port for the 2021 Cape Vintage

KWV senior winemakers Kobus van der Merwe and Izele van Blerk
with the Investec Trophy for the Most Successful Producer
They also received Gold for KWV Cathedral Cellar Sauvignon Blanc 2023

The full list of winners can be seen HERE
Wines we were served with lunch came from this list. All had been entered into the competition
and we had fun pairing as many as we could with the food and tasting

All our stories can be seen in the Blog Archive near the top of the column on the right

If you do not wish to receive e-mails from us, please email menucape@gmail.com with the word 'UNSUBSCRIBE' in your email